Colorado Title Insurance for Historic Homes: What Buyers and Sellers Need to Know
- Jerad Larkin
- 7 hours ago
- 6 min read
What makes buying a historic home in Colorado so unique - and why does title insurance matter even more?
If you’ve ever walked through Denver’s Capitol Hill, Baker, or Cheesman Park neighborhoods, you’ve seen the kind of timeless character that makes Colorado’s historic homes so special. But behind that charm often lies a complicated ownership history - and that’s where title insurance becomes a vital part of protecting your investment. Whether you’re buying a century-old bungalow in Colorado Springs or selling a restored Victorian in Denver, understanding how title insurance for historic homes works can save you from major legal and financial headaches down the road.
Why Historic Homes Require Special Attention in Colorado
Historic homes are a big part of Colorado’s identity - but they also come with unique challenges that newer properties rarely face. Many of these properties were built long before modern zoning, subdivision, and record-keeping laws existed.
Common traits of Colorado’s historic homes
Built before 1940, often with mixed materials and early construction methods.
May be registered with local or national historic districts.
Often have undergone multiple renovations, additions, or ownership changes.
Can include shared driveways, boundary overlaps, or easement confusion.
These characteristics make title research and insurance coverage more complex. Older records may not be fully digitized, and property boundaries may not align perfectly with today’s plat maps.
That’s why working with a title company experienced in historic properties - like Chicago Title Colorado - is critical.
Common Title Issues with Historic Properties
Because these homes often date back 80–120 years, their title history can be surprisingly tangled. Here are some of the most frequent issues that surface during title searches:
🔹 1. Missing or incomplete records
Early Colorado property records were handwritten, stored on microfilm, or even lost to fire or water damage. This can make tracing ownership back to the original plat challenging.
🔹 2. Boundary or easement disputes
Historic properties may have shared alleys, encroachments, or fencing conflicts. These are especially common in neighborhoods like Five Points or Old Colorado City where parcels were redrawn multiple times.
🔹 3. Unreleased liens or mortgages
A prior owner’s loan payoff may never have been properly recorded. That “phantom lien” can appear decades later and delay your closing.
🔹 4. Restrictive covenants
Some historic homes were originally part of large estates or subdivisions that carried restrictions - such as architectural limitations or even discriminatory covenants that remain recorded but unenforceable.
🔹 5. Probate or inheritance claims
Homes that have stayed in families for generations may have unclear estate transfers. A distant heir can resurface with a claim to partial ownership if the probate wasn’t properly handled. These are exactly the kinds of problems title insurance protects against.
How Title Insurance Protects Owners of Historic Homes
Title insurance ensures that once you close on your historic Colorado property, your ownership is secure - no matter what old record, lien, or heir might surface later.
Owner’s Policy Protection
An Owner’s Title Insurance Policy protects your financial interest for as long as you own the home. It covers:
Legal defense if someone challenges your ownership.
Losses due to title defects that existed before you bought the property.
Hidden risks like forged documents, filing errors, or undisclosed heirs.
Lender’s Policy Protection
If you have a mortgage, your lender will require a Lender’s Title Policy. It ensures that their interest in the property remains valid if a title issue arises.
Why it matters more for historic homes
Because historic homes have longer chains of ownership, there’s more opportunity for gaps in documentation. A small clerical error from 1915 could cost you thousands without proper coverage. That’s why Chicago Title Colorado conducts enhanced title searches and curative work for older properties to ensure clean, insurable title before closing.
The Closing Process for Historic Homes in Colorado
Closing on a historic home in Colorado follows the same general steps as any other transaction - but with additional research and verification layers.
1. Title Search and Examination
The title company reviews every recorded document tied to the property: deeds, easements, plats, and liens. For older properties, this can go back a century or more.
2. Issue Resolution
If problems appear - say, a missing release or boundary confusion — the title company works with the seller, county clerk, or past lenders to clear the issue.
3. Policy Issuance
Once the title is clear, Chicago Title Colorado issues both the owner’s and lender’s policies. These policies provide peace of mind that your property rights are protected.
4. Escrow and Closing
Historic home closings may also require coordination with local preservation boards, insurance carriers, or contractors performing approved renovations. Chicago Title Colorado’s escrow team in Denver and Colorado Springs is equipped to handle these complex transactions smoothly.
Choosing the Best Title Company for Historic Homes in Denver and Colorado Springs
Not all title companies are equal - and historic homes require experience.
What to look for:
Experience with pre-war homes and older subdivisions.
Strong local relationships with county assessors and recorders.
Familiarity with preservation easements and historic designations.
Access to archival data that isn’t digitized.
Why choose Chicago Title Colorado
With offices across the Front Range, Chicago Title Colorado has been helping homeowners and agents close on historic homes for decades. They’re not just processing paperwork - they’re uncovering history, protecting legacies, and ensuring every document is airtight before you sign.
Real-World Examples: Denver’s Historic Districts & Case Studies
Capitol Hill, Denver
A buyer discovered that a portion of their backyard was technically part of a neighboring parcel from 1899. Chicago Title’s team researched and filed the necessary corrective deeds before closing, avoiding months of delay.
Old Colorado City, Colorado Springs
A historic craftsman bungalow had a 1930s deed restriction prohibiting detached garages. Chicago Title worked with the city to verify the covenant’s expiration, clearing the path for modern improvements.
Highlands District, Denver
A title search revealed a 1941 tax lien never formally released. The company located archived county records proving payment, then filed a satisfaction document. Without that work, the buyer could have inherited a phantom debt.
Each case underscores the value of having a title partner who knows Colorado’s history inside and out.
Key Tips for Real Estate Agents Handling Historic Properties
Agents representing buyers or sellers of historic homes can protect their clients — and themselves - by partnering with an experienced title professional early in the process.
Here’s how:
Order the title commitment early. Historic home issues often surface late. Starting the title search during listing preparation can prevent last-minute chaos.
Verify property boundaries and easements. A quick look at the assessor’s parcel map isn’t enough. Request surveys or archived plats if available.
Understand local preservation rules. Denver, Colorado Springs, and other municipalities have varying renovation restrictions. These may affect insurability or buyer financing.
Educate your clients on title insurance benefits. Many buyers underestimate the value of title protection until something goes wrong.
Collaborate with trusted partners. Chicago Title Colorado frequently hosts classes for agents on complex transactions like these - giving Realtors a leg up when navigating historic home sales.
Why Jerad Larkin and Chicago Title Colorado Are the Best Choice
When you work with Jerad Larkin and Chicago Title Colorado, you’re partnering with a team that understands not just real estate, but the stories behind Colorado’s homes.
Jerad’s expertise goes beyond paperwork. He helps agents and homeowners:
Navigate the nuances of historic preservation and title defects.
Understand every step of the closing process.
Access valuable real estate tools that make marketing and transactions easier.
If you want a smooth closing backed by decades of trust and the power of one of the best title insurance companies in Colorado, Chicago Title Colorado is your go-to resource.
Conclusion
Owning a piece of Colorado history is an incredible opportunity - but it also comes with responsibility. Title insurance isn’t just a formality; it’s your safeguard against the unknown past of your property. From Denver’s Queen Annes to Colorado Springs’ Craftsman bungalows, every home has a story. Make sure yours has a clear title chapter.
Questions? Contact:
📞 Jerad Larkin – Chicago Title Colorado
For tools, resources, and exclusive real estate event invites, subscribe at MileHighTitleGuy.com
Comments