Why the Bank's Appraisal Decides Your Short Sale

Jerad Larkin
44 minutes ago
7 min read

Why does the bank appraisal matter so much in a short sale? The bank's appraisal or BPO sets the net the lender requires. Once that number is in their system it is very hard to change, so meeting the appraiser at the property is your only real chance to influence the outcome.

There was a moment in the short sale class I sat in on where the instructor stopped, backed up, and said some version of: this is the most important part of a short sale, and I mean it, this is the most important part.

She was talking about the appraisal. And after listening to the full three hours, I think she is right, and I think it is the single most underused piece of leverage agents have in these deals.

Here is why.

The Appraisal Sets the Net

Walk through the sequence of what happens behind the scenes.

You submit the short sale package
The bank collects documents and eventually assigns a negotiator
The negotiator orders a BPO or a full appraisal (FHA and VA get a full appraisal)
That value goes into their system
Every number the bank demands is calculated off that value

Step 4 is the moment the deal is decided.

On an FHA file, the Approval to Participate letter is generated from that appraised value: 88% of it in the first 30 days, then 86%, then 84%. On other loan types, the net requirement comes off the same number.

And once it is in the system, arguing is close to pointless. The negotiator's answer, which is honestly a fair one, is: I am not the valuation professional, an appraiser went out there and told me what it is worth.

So you get one shot, and the shot happens on the day the appraiser walks the property.

Here Is the Part That Feels Backwards

You want this appraisal to come in as low as possible.

Every instinct you have built as an agent runs the other direction. Normally when an appraiser shows up you are talking the property up, because your buyer needs the loan to work. You point out the upgrades. You leave the good comps on the counter.

Do the opposite here. And it is worth understanding exactly why, because it is not a trick, it is just how the transaction is structured.

This appraisal has nothing to do with the buyer. The buyer's lender will order their own appraisal. This one exists for exactly one purpose: to tell the bank how much money to demand from the sale.

So a low value hurts absolutely nobody.

If you have a $350,000 offer in hand and the bank's value comes in at $325,000, the negotiator's response is essentially: great, we accept, thank you. Nobody loses their financing. Nobody's deal falls apart. The seller gets out from under the house, and the deficiency is smaller.

A high value is what kills the deal. If it comes in above what the market will actually pay, the bank's position becomes: that is the value, and until we foreclose, that is what we need. And now you are stuck marketing a property at a price no buyer will meet.

How to Actually Work the Appraisal

The baseline recommendation from the class was to at minimum have a conversation with the appraiser. The better version is to meet them at the property.

Here is what to bring.

1. The bad comps, and why they are bad

If there is a sale down the street $50,000 higher, do not hope the appraiser misses it. Get ahead of it.

"Please do not use 1234 Elm as a comp. It is a full remodel, it has the largest lot in the subdivision, and it has a finished basement this one does not."

The concern here, said plainly, is that an appraiser under time pressure grabs the three easiest comps, averages them, and drops a number in the system. Your job is to make the easy path the accurate path.

2. Your own comps

Bring properties in genuinely comparable condition. This is the CMA work you already know how to do, aimed at a different target.

3. The inspection, if you have one

This is the highest value item on the list, and it is the reason to push for an early inspection date in the contract.

Roof issues. Sewer issues. Anything structural. These are things an appraiser cannot see on a walkthrough, and the bank's value is an as is value, because the seller has no money for repairs and the bank does not own the property so it legally cannot repair it either.

An inspection report with a real defect on it is a documented, third party argument for a lower value. There is nothing else in the process that works as well.

4. The listing history

This one gets skipped and it should not.

If the property has been on the market a while, especially if it started as a normal sale, went to break even, and only became a short sale after that, you have a paper trail. Price drops. Showing counts. Feedback saying it is overpriced.

Part of what a home is worth is what someone is actually willing to pay for it, and you can prove nobody was willing.

5. Everything else that is wrong with it

Whatever it is. It smells. The layout is bad. There are solar panels on a lease that shrink the buyer pool, which is a legitimate value argument, not a complaint.

Anything negative and true is worth saying.

The Showing Access Trick

This is a small operational detail that could cost you the entire deal, and I had not heard it before.

Some appraisers are booking access through automated showing services and walking the property without ever contacting the listing agent. You find out after the fact, when the value has already been submitted, and your one opportunity is gone.

When you hear the appraisal has been ordered, turn off automatic access. Switch the listing to "contact agent for access."

Now they have to call you. And when they call you, you get to say you will meet them there.

That is it. That is the whole trick, and it is the difference between having your one shot and not having it.

If the Value Comes in Too High Anyway

It happens. Here is what is worth trying, in order.

Flag it immediately. If the number is meaningfully off, take it to the negotiator right away, not three weeks later. Sometimes they can go back to the appraiser, particularly if you can point at something concrete, like comps pulled from a completely different neighborhood or a new construction subdivision.

Write the best rebuttal you can. They will give you the appraisal. Go comp by comp and explain what is wrong with each one. Attach better comps.

Critical detail: use sold comps from the date of the appraisal, not from today. Agents send current comps and it does not work. It has to be an apples to apples comparison against the same time period the appraiser was working in.

Use the inspection. This is the approach with the best track record. If the buyers did an inspection and found something significant, a sewer line, a roof, send the findings with contractor bids and make the request specific: the buyers will still close, but they need the price reduced by the cost of the repair, and here is the bid.

The banks do care about that. They do not care about a list of small items and a request to knock a thousand dollars off. Save the ask for something real.

Understand the timing. Appraisals expire. If enough time passes and the file gets reworked, a new value may get ordered, which is both an opportunity and a risk. It is also why, if a buyer walks after approval, you should put "previously approved at" in the MLS rather than "approved at."

Why This Is the Skill Worth Building

Most of a short sale is administrative. Collect documents, submit them, follow up, submit more documents, follow up again. It is work, but it is not skilled work, and a coordinator can do most of it for you.

The appraisal conversation is different. It is judgment, preparation, and local market knowledge, and it happens once. Two agents can run the identical file and get outcomes $40,000 apart based entirely on whether one of them showed up with an inspection report and a listing history and the other let the appraiser walk the house alone.

That is worth practicing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should an agent meet the appraiser on a short sale?

Yes. It is the only meaningful opportunity to influence the value, and the value determines the net the lender requires. Bring negative comps, your own comps, any inspection findings, and the listing history showing price drops and showing feedback.

Why do you want a low appraisal on a short sale?

Because the bank's appraisal only determines how much the lender will require from the sale. It does not affect the buyer's financing, since the buyer's lender orders a separate appraisal. A lower value means a lower required net, which makes the deal easier to close and reduces the seller's deficiency.

Can a short sale appraisal be disputed?

It can be challenged, but success is limited. Flag a bad value with the negotiator immediately, submit sold comps from the date of the appraisal rather than current comps, and explain specifically why the appraiser's comps were not comparable. The most effective approach is submitting inspection findings with contractor bids for major defects.

Does the buyer still need their own appraisal on a short sale?

Yes. The bank's appraisal is for the lender taking the loss and has no bearing on the buyer's financing. The buyer's lender will order its own appraisal as part of normal loan underwriting.

This post is part of a series I built from a three hour short sale CE class taught by a negotiator with roughly 1,500 closings behind her. The full walkthrough is here: Short Sales in Colorado: The Complete Guide for Real Estate Agents.

My Blog